Huge Opportunity in Seffner – 5/4.5 with Pool on an Acre

This 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath home has 3,932 square feet on a 44,400-square-foot lot, with a screen-enclosed swimming pool and a 3-car garage. The has includes multiple living and dining areas, and a fireplace. The roof was replaced in 2018, and the two HVAC systems were replaced in 2018 and 2020. Electrical and plumbing are in good working order, with well and septic service. The kitchen is functional but dated, the bathrooms are older, and the house needs paint and flooring. One water heater dates to 2020, while the second is original to 1983. The property is in FEMA Flood Zone AE and will be vacant at closing. Pemberton Creek currently has no active resale listings.

Estimated Repairs Needed

• Update the kitchen, including cabinetry, counters, backsplash, fixtures, appliances, and lighting.
• Update the bathrooms and repair cracked or loose tile, worn vanity and cabinet finishes, aged grout and caulk, plumbing fixtures, and damaged toilet components.
• Replace worn carpet, repair isolated damaged tile, patch garage and lanai ceiling seams and cracks, and complete interior paint and finish updates.
• Repair exterior stucco cracks and chips, clean staining and mildew-like surface growth, complete exterior paint, and trim landscaping away from the structure.
• Clean and repair the pool enclosure and screen-door areas, address isolated damaged or displaced deck pavers, and inspect the pool equipment and finish.
• Evaluate the older porch-roof covering, replace the original water heater, service both HVAC systems, and inspect the well and septic systems.

Comparable Sales

1. 2514 Martucci Rd — 0.58 mile away; 4/3; 3,299 square feet; sold May 2026 for $875,000; 1.68-acre lot; screened saltwater pool and spa; 3-car garage. This extensively renovated 2008 estate had a high-end kitchen and finished outdoor living areas. It is newer and sits on a larger lot, while the subject has more living area, bedrooms, and bathrooms.
2. 6810 Luana Ln — 0.30 mile away; 3/4; 3,813 square feet; sold December 2025 for $1,200,000; 1-acre lot; heated screened saltwater pool and spa; 9-car garage. This fully renovated estate included a pool house, theater, outdoor kitchens, premium finishes, and creek frontage. Its acreage and living area are close, but the garage capacity, waterfront, accessory improvements, and finish level are materially superior.
3. 2703 Pemberton Creek Dr — 0.27 mile away; 5/5; 4,204 square feet; sold February 2026 for $520,000; 0.98-acre lot; screened pool, spa, and sauna; 3-car garage. This 1985 home had a 2023 roof, updated HVAC systems, wood kitchen cabinets, newer appliances, and an updated pool bathroom, but it was not renovated to a top retail finish. Its size, age, bedroom count, acreage, pool, and garage closely match the subject and support the lower condition bracket.

ARV & Rental Analysis

Estimated ARV: $850,000 to $925,000 +/-

Estimated Rent: $4,500 to $5,100 per month +/-