Super Clean St Augustine SFR

This Anastasia Island house mostly remodeled already, concrete block/stucco, and sits between the ocean and Intracoastal.  It has 5 beds / 3 baths, 2,220 sq. ft., a metal roof, central HVAC, and an 8,712 sq. ft. lot. One of the beds is a converted garage/studio with its own entrance.  The previous owner had  replaced windows/doors, recently painted exterior, remodeled kitchen and baths, good roof condition, good HVAC, good plumbing, and only light cosmetic items remaining. We have won this at an auction and are marketing our contract.  Flood zone is AE.

Repairs Needed

• Light cosmetic touchups
• Add refrigerator
• Light exterior cleanup and maybe some paint

Comparable Sales

1. 210 Flagler Blvd | 4/2 | 1,787 SF | Closed Jun 8, 2026 | $599,900 | $336/SF | 0.69 mi | 2-car garage – best MLS-supported comp; smaller than subject but marketed as former Airbnb/revenue property. Strong upper support.
2. 201 Kenan St | 4/2 | 1,534 SF | Closed Mar 26, 2026 | $550,000 | $359/SF | 0.08 mi | No garage – very close sale and strong location support, but condition is not verified in the CMA. Useful, but not enough by itself to push value high.
3. 500 Arricola Ave | 3/2 | 1,791 SF | Closed Jan 14, 2026 | $525,000 | $293/SF | 0.04 mi | 1-car garage – very close and similar lot size, but smaller and inferior bed/bath count.
4. 105 Arricola Ave Apt B | 3/2.5 | 1,586 SF | Closed Jan 12, 2026 | $450,000 | $284/SF | 0.72 mi | No garage – smaller lot and weaker support; mostly a floor, not the target.

ARV & Rental Analysis

Estimated practical ARV: $585,000 to $599,000 +/-

Estimated rent: $3,200 to $3,800/month +/-