South Tampa 4/2 Pool Home

This two-story 1958 South Tampa home offers 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1,868 sq ft of living area and a screen-enclosed pool on a 6,539 sq ft lot. The property requires a full renovation, including the kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, wall and ceiling finishes, paint, fixtures and pool area. Seller reports a 2016 roof and paid-off solar panel system. Seller will need 30 days of post-possession secured by a $20,000 holdback.

Repairs Needed (Estimated)

• Remove remaining contents and debris after possession is delivered
• Full kitchen renovation
• Renovate both bathrooms
• Replace outdated flooring throughout
• Remove or update wall paneling, wallpaper and dated ceiling finishes
• Repair drywall and complete interior and exterior paint
• Replace interior doors, trim, lighting, hardware and fixtures
• Inspect the 2016 roof, roof decking and solar attachment points
• Service the pool, pool equipment, deck and screen enclosure
• Complete exterior cleanup and landscaping

Comparable Sales

1. 4116 W Iowa Ave – 4/2, 1,740 sq ft, built in 1958, sold February 2026 for $577,500. Completely renovated with a new roof, windows, HVAC, electrical, plumbing, kitchen and bathrooms. Strong age and bedroom comparison, but superior with a quarter-acre lot and two-car garage; it does not have a pool.
2. 4404 W Wisconsin Ave – 4/2, 1,614 sq ft, built in 1956, sold June 2026 for $550,000. Updated pool home with an open floor plan, renovated kitchen, heated saltwater pool, screen enclosure and maintained interior. Smaller than the subject but highly relevant for age, condition and pool appeal.
3. 4108 W Marietta St – 3/2, 1,340 sq ft, built in 1958, sold May 2026 for $526,500. Updated pool home with a hot tub, screened lanai, turf yard, 2021 roof and 2022 HVAC. Substantially smaller with one fewer bedroom.
4. 4115 W Bay Ave – 3/2, 1,568 sq ft, built in 1958, sold March 2026 for $520,000. Fully renovated with a redesigned kitchen, updated bathrooms, flooring, paint, metal roof and covered carport. Smaller with one fewer bedroom and no pool.
5. 4209 Ohio Ave – 4/2, 1,526 sq ft, built in 1958, sold July 2026 for $499,990. Well-maintained home with an updated interior, oversized 10,220 sq ft lot and above-ground pool. Smaller than the subject but substantially superior in lot size.
6. 4006 W Wisconsin Ave – 4/2, 1,599 sq ft, built in 1958, sold February 2026 for $450,000. Renovated with an updated kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, paint and one-car garage, but without a pool. Its older finishes and lower sale establish the conservative end of the renovated market.

ARV & Rental Analysis

Estimated ARV: $550,000 to $575,000 +/-

Estimated Rent: $3,400 to $3,700 per month +/-